The Hidden Realities of Raising a Child with Selective Mutism: What No One Tells You

Having a child with selective mutism goes way beyond just having a child who struggles to speak...here's what I wish I'd been prepared for.

Selective mutism is described as 'an anxiety disorder where a child can speak freely in some places but becomes unable to speak in others'. That definition is technically correct — but it barely scratches the surface of what life is actually like for families living with it every day.

When my own child first showed signs of selective mutism, I knew what selective mutism was (I used to be a teacher), but I thought it was 'just' difficulty with speaking when anxious (as if that isn't hard enough!)

I had no idea how much it would shape our routines, our relationships, our identity as a family, and my identity as a mother. There are realities no one warns you about — the quiet, complicated, exhausting parts that happen behind closed doors.

This is what it’s really like.

1. Children with selective mutism are often anxious in other areas as well, not just anxious to speak.

Selective mutism rarely shows up on its own — children with selective mutism have more sensitive nervous systems and often experience other anxieties (Driessen et al., 2020) especially social anxiety separation anxiety (Gensthaler et al., 2016) and social anxiety. Bedtimes can stretch long into the evening. School drop‑offs can feel like emotional cliff‑edges. Social events like parties and playdates can become really challenging too, for the child and the parent.

Because here's the thing: you become the safe person, the safe place, the constant. And that constancy shapes everything from morning routines to how you move around your own home. We have had multiple struggles with anxiety with our daughter. I wish I'd been prepared for this reality, because it's honestly been much harder than I was prepared for.

2. Progress in selective mutism is very possible - but it's often much slower than we want it to be

People love a quick fix story. I definitely love a quick fix story. Selective mutism doesn’t offer one.

Progress happens, absolutely — but it’s slow, steady, and often invisible to everyone except you. A whisper to a teacher might be the biggest milestone of the year. You celebrate it quietly, while others say, “Is that it?”

Something that parents I support often struggle with managing expectations of progress. It's taken me a really long time to really believe this too, but here are the truths about progress:

• It really is a case of slow and steady wins the race

• Often as soon as we see a bit of progress we want to race ahead - this can add pressure to our child (which will backfire) and end with us feeling demoralised

• Progress isn't linear - sometimes they will seem to make progress and then the next day you feel like you've gone back two steps. This is normal - progress is never linear in any area of life.

• Sometimes progress is actually invisible. Here's what I mean: as soon as they've made progress (e.g., they spoke to their teacher), we want to move on to saying more words, or speaking louder, or speaking to a different teacher. But actually, when they seem to stay at the same level, speaking again to the same teacher, every time they do it this behaviour becomes easier and easier - and this is something to celebrate, rather than worrying why they're not moving ahead to the next rung of the ladder.

• Sometimes they just aren't making progress in their speaking, but they may well be making progress over their anxiety in another area (maybe they are finding it easier to go to clubs, or to go to sleep quicker).

3. They’re chatterboxes at home - so people don't believe you.

This is one of the most misunderstood parts: At home, they’re loud, funny, opinionated, dramatic, and full of personality. They talk nonstop. They sing. They argue. They narrate their entire day.

So when you tell people they can’t speak at school, they look at you like you’re exaggerating. You know the truth: it's like having two different children. Others see a child who's 'just shy'. It’s a painful kind of disbelief.

4. Selective mutism is a physical freeze, not a conscious choice

Selective mutism isn’t stubbornness. It isn’t defiance. It isn’t a choice. When they freeze, their body is in fight/flight/freeze. Their throat tightens. Their muscles lock. Their voice literally cannot come out. I'll never forget how my daughter's face used to freeze and go into sheer panic, as she'd look at me, wide-eyed like a deer caught in the headlights, absolutely petrified.

Once you’ve seen that freeze up close, you never mistake it for “won’t”. It is always “can’t”. I can't tell you how many times I've explained this to people, and they still talk about my daughter "not wanting to talk" or that "she'll speak when she wants to." It's incredibly frustrating, especially when you know that they would love nothing more than to be able to speak.

5. You become a Velcro family.

Selective mutism creates a kind of closeness that is both beautiful and exhausting. You're your child's safe nervous system, and they come to rely on you in those situations where speech might be expected...or where they might feel anxious.

Your child might not let you leave the room. Drop‑offs become impossible without you. Even going to the toilet alone can trigger panic. You become Velcro — stuck together because separation feels unsafe. This can be really hard, because others see this as a clingy child, and an over-indulgent parent.

I remember taking my daughter on a playdate years ago and being told by the mother that I was being too overprotective by staying at the playdate. But the reality with selective mutism is this: I stay (at least to begin with) so that her nervous system calms down, so that I can relax her, so that I can warm up her voice and have her speak in front of people. This is to help her make progress, not to be overprotective.

6. You become the expert, advocate...and exhausted parent.

You learn everything you can: the research, the strategies, the language of anxiety. Not because you want to, but because you have to. You have to because your child needs you to do the things that help them overcome selective mutism - and you're with them more than anybody else.

You explain selective mutism to teachers, relatives, and professionals — sometimes repeatedly. You fight for accommodations while running on empty. You become the bridge between your child and the world.

7. School takes enormous energy for children with selective mutism - and home gets the fall out

School is a marathon of masking, freezing, and managing anxiety. By the time they get home — their safe place — the exhaustion hits. Meltdowns, tears, irritability. Not because they’re “being difficult”, but because they’ve held it together all day. They're finally in a place where they can speak freely, where it's easy. Others see an easy and compliant child, who was "fine at school" - we see a child who is barely holding it together.

8. There’s a grief you don't expect

You grieve the easy school run you thought you’d have. You grieve the simple childhood moments that now come with complexity. You grieve the freedom other families seem to have. You grieve how easy and carefree you thought their childhood would be.

It’s a quiet grief, but it’s real. And, to be honest, there can be envy too.

9. Siblings are impacted too

Siblings often become protectors, interpreters, or emotional buffers. Some step into a helper role. Others feel overshadowed. All are affected. Selective mutism doesn’t just belong to one child — it touches the whole family system. My younger daughter reads her sister, and launches into clown mode to appease her, or cheer her up, or distract her. Yes, it's wonderful, but she's carrying an emotional obligation I don't want her to have to carry.

10. You feel alone - because selective mutism is rare, and misunderstood.

Selective mutism affects around 1 in 140 children (Bergman et al., 2002). That's quite rare. When we first started on our journey through selective mutism, very few people had heard of it....and most inside still thought it was just a 'shy child', and an overzealous mother attributing things to anxiety instead of just letting her build confidence and grow out of it.

You can feel isolated, even in a room full of parents, because nobody else has the same challenge. You can feel unseen, even when you’re doing everything you can. But you’re not alone — even if it feels that way.

11. Eating, drinking and toileting can be affected too.

The freeze response doesn’t only affect speech. Some children can’t eat or drink at school. Some can’t use the toilet. Their body stays in shutdown mode until they’re home and safe. They will often be unable to access help and attention, even when they are able to speak - this is another challenge we deal with.

12. The hardest words are the smallest ones

Hello. Thank you. Please.

These tiny social words carry huge pressure. They’re often the hardest for children with selective mutism to say — and the ones adults expect most. They have likely heard a nudge or request to say these words hundreds of times, or sensed judgement or disapproval when they haven't.

The Truth Beneath It All

Raising a child with selective mutism is a journey of patience, advocacy, emotional and mental labour, and fierce love. It’s demanding. It’s misunderstood. It’s lonely at times.

But it’s also full of quiet victories, deep connection, and a resilience that grows in both you and your child. Progress is possible. Hope is real. And you are doing far better than you think.

Looking for support? Book a free call to talk about where you are right now and how I can support you.

---

About the Author

Katrina Batey is a trained S.P.A.C.E. anxiety treatment provider, mental health coach, and parent to a daughter who had selective mutism and other anxiety challenges. She supports families across the UK and internationally to help children with selective mutism and anxiety to overcome these challenges, and build confidence and resilience. Learn more about Katrina.

References

Bergman RL, Piacentini J, McCracken JT. Prevalence and description of selective mutism in a school-based sample. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. (2002)

Driessen, J., Blom, J.D., Muris, P. et al. Anxiety in Children with Selective Mutism: A Meta-analysis. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev 51, 330–341 (2020)

Gensthaler A, Maichrowitz V, Kaess M, Ligges M, Freitag CM, Schwenck C. Selective Mutism: The Fraternal Twin of Childhood Social Phobia. Psychopathology. (2016)